Gas Calculation for Inflatable Cabinets
As is well known, SF6 is a greenhouse gas, and emitting 1 ton of SF6 is equivalent to emitting 23500 tons of CO2. Therefore, the degree of harm can be imagined, and it is necessary to make every effort to achieve SF6 removal in switchgear. SF6 gas has excellent insulation and breaking performance.
Especially in the application of high voltage and ultra-high voltage fields, there is currently no suitable single gas that can achieve complete substitution of SF6 gas. Mixing SF6 gas with other N2/CO2 gases can partially reduce SF6 usage. 3M's new gas perfluoroisobutyronitrile (C4F7N, abbreviated as C4 below) and perfluoron-propylethylene (C5F10O, abbreviated as C5 below) both have good insulation properties, but the boiling point of a single gas is very high, and it must be mixed with other gases to reduce the boiling point and meet the application environment requirements of switchgear at -25 degrees Celsius (some applications require minus 40 degrees Celsius). Therefore, it is necessary to calculate the weight of each component of the mixed gas, as well as the cost and global warming potential GWP of the entire mixed gas. To obtain the best solution for replacing gases.
Using the C-GIS inflatable cabinet with a voltage of 40.5kV as an example for calculation. The volume of the C-GIS gas tank is 824 liters, with an inflation pressure of 0.36 bar. To calculate the gas mass, it needs to be calculated based on absolute pressure, which is 1.36 bar. The molar mass of SF6 is 146, so it is calculated according to the formula: gas mass=(inflation pressure * volume * molar mass)/(R * T). The EXCEL calculation result is as follows. The C-GIS requires filling SF6 gas with a mass of 6.8 kg, approximately equal to 15 lbs. Calculated at 0.13 yuan per gram, the cost of SF6 gas is 884 yuan.
There are several SF6 replacement schemes, one of which is to reduce the use of SF6 and mix nitrogen or CO2 gas. Taking 50% SF6+50% N2 as an example, this scheme is applied to the early Tianling 40.5kV inflatable cabinet (12kV 100% N2, 24kV 90% N2+10% SF6), and the mixed gas is calculated at a filling pressure of 1,4-bar. Based on a pressure ratio of 50%, the SF6 gas pressure can be calculated to be 0.7 bar, with a volume of 824 liters, and the SF6 gas mass can be calculated to be 3.5 kg. Using the same method to calculate the nitrogen gas mass, the molar mass of nitrogen is 28, resulting in a nitrogen gas mass of 0.67 kg and a cost of 33.55 yuan. Therefore, the total cost of replacing the mixed gas is 488 yuan.
For a mixture of multiple gases, using the same method, such as a mixture of 6% C4, 10% oxygen, and 84% carbon dioxide, the calculation results are as follows.
The calculation results are as follows.
Due to the higher cost of C4, the total cost of mixed gas is 1315 yuan more expensive than pure SF6 gas, resulting in a 149% increase in cost. The global warming potential (GWP) is 542, a decrease of 97.69% compared to 23500, indicating a significant reduction in greenhouse effect.
It can be seen that although C4 is a greenhouse gas, due to its small proportion, its greenhouse effect is significantly reduced compared to SF6. Compared to SF6 mixed with nitrogen or carbon dioxide, even with 10% SF6, the greenhouse effect GWP is still very large. Of course, C5 is also a good choice besides its high cost.
Recently Posted
-
Comparison of Applicability between UL1558 Switchgear and UL891 Distribution Panel
November 16, 2026The UL1558 SWITCHGEAR switchgear is larger and more expensive than the UL891 SWITCHBOARD distribution panel, but more reliable, wh
Read More -
Plum blossom contact temperature rise solution
November 13, 2026The most difficult point to solve the temperature rise of the central circuit breaker switchgear is the connection point of the pr
Read More -
Differences in central cabinets
November 13, 2026Differences in central cabinetsMany mid mounted cabinets look similar in appearance, and some have well crafted details that give
Read More -
Requirements and Solutions for Switchgear in Foreign Projects
November 11, 2026Introduction With the going global of domestic products and the construction of the the Belt and Road, more and more Chinese switc
Read More